Skip to content
505-226-3205
Gauthier & Maier Law Firm, P.C. Logo
  • Practice Areas
    • Truck Accidents
    • Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Nursing Home Injuries and Abuse
    • Wrongful Death
    • Slip and Falll Accidents
  • About Our Firm
    • Attorneys and Staff
    • Case Results
    • Client Testimonials
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Personal Injury FAQ
    • Personal Injury Claims Process
  • Locations
    • Albuquerque
    • Los Lunas
  • Contact Us
Schedule a Free Consultation

Who Can Be Held Liable for a Truck Accident?

Home  >  Blog  >  Who Can Be Held Liable for a Truck Accident?

May 10, 2025 | By Gauthier & Maier Law Firm, P.C.
Who Can Be Held Liable for a Truck Accident?

Commercial trucks move the goods that fuel businesses, fill homes, and keep the economy moving. But when a massive eighteen-wheeler crashes into a passenger vehicle, the fallout can be devastating – and the story behind the crash is rarely simple. When you’ve suffered an injury in a collision with a truck, you might expect the driver to be the only one at fault. That assumption often leaves out the bigger picture.

Truck accidents aren’t like typical car accidents. Behind every truck is a network of decisions, responsibilities, and contracts – each potentially tied to the moment of impact. A driver may be the last link in the chain, but liability often stretches far beyond the person behind the wheel. Understanding who’s truly accountable takes more than guesswork. A skilled truck accident lawyer will dig into every angle before any paperwork lands on a court docket.

Schedule A Free Consultation Today

It Doesn’t Always Start with the Driver

Truck drivers make mistakes like anyone else. They speed. They get distracted. They misjudge distances. When a driver’s actions directly cause a crash, they can be held accountable. But trucking is a business, which means someone else usually puts that driver on the road.

Sometimes, drivers are employees, and sometimes, they’re considered independent contractors. That legal distinction matters, but it’s not the end of the discussion. Even when a driver works independently, a seasoned truck accident attorney will look at the company that hired them, the training they received, and the expectations they were under. If a company forced a driver to meet impossible deadlines, looked the other way on safety concerns, or handed over the keys to someone with a questionable record, that decision can carry weight long before a lawsuit begins.

A driver’s logbook, digital trip records, dispatch communications, and service hour data will all be examined. A lawyer won’t just accept surface-level facts. They’ll piece together the timeline leading up to the crash and determine whether pressure from above played a role.

Trucking Companies Don’t Get a Free Pass

car accident between an orange truck and a passenger car. traffic accident. close-up

You might assume the driver’s employer will accept responsibility when their truck causes a serious collision. But trucking companies rarely admit fault without resistance. These businesses often have risk departments and legal teams that kick into gear the moment a wreck is reported. That’s why the early steps taken by a truck accident attorney will shape the rest of the case.

A company can be responsible for more than just the driver’s actions. If the truck wasn’t maintained properly, the tires were worn, or the brakes were faulty, that reflects on the company’s commitment to safety – or lack of it. Your lawyer will gather maintenance logs, inspection reports, and mechanic invoices to determine if routine upkeep was skipped or delayed.

Hiring decisions also matter. If a company knew – or should’ve known – that a driver had a dangerous driving history or lacked proper licensing, those decisions won’t be ignored. An attorney will obtain personnel records and background checks during the early discovery phase, setting the stage for a powerful argument before a case ever heads to court.

Manufacturers Can Be Part of the Story

Some crashes are not due to human error at all. When equipment fails, the fault may rest with those who designed or manufactured it. A defective steering system, malfunctioning trailer hitch, or flawed braking system can all lead to disaster on the highway.

If a truck had a part that was later recalled or flagged for safety concerns, that information can change everything. An experienced truck accident attorney will examine whether the manufacturer failed to warn the company or correct a known issue. Technical reports, safety bulletins, and federal recall databases will be used to build a foundation before the case moves into formal litigation.

Even if the faulty part wasn’t subject to a recall, the manufacturer can still be held accountable under product liability laws. A lawyer will consult engineering reports and work with outside specialists to assess whether the component was inherently dangerous. These assessments begin in the pre-lawsuit phase, giving your legal team time to develop a persuasive and well-documented claim.

Cargo Loaders Aren’t Off the Hook

Truck cargo isn’t just tossed into a trailer and forgotten. There are procedures for securing freight, distributing weight evenly, and confirming that nothing will shift during transit. When those steps are skipped or rushed, a crash becomes more likely – especially on sharp turns, hills, or sudden stops.

The person or company that loaded the trailer might seem removed from the crash, but they can play a central role in what happened. If a truck jackknifed or tipped because the load was unbalanced, the loading crew’s actions matter. A truck accident attorney will examine the bill of lading, weigh station reports, and loading protocols to see if a separate party mishandled this part of the journey.

In many cases, the trucking company doesn’t employ the loading crew. That’s what makes this aspect so important. If an independent warehouse team contributed to the crash, they can be added as a party before litigation begins. Your lawyer will preserve evidence and send early legal notices so important records aren’t destroyed before your claim gains traction.

Third-Party Contractors Make Things Complicated

Trucking often involves multiple layers of subcontracting. A carrier might own the truck but lease it to another company. That second company might then subcontract with a freight broker or dispatch service. Each of these links has its own contracts, obligations, and insurance policies – and any one of them might be responsible in some way.

Your attorney will break down those business relationships early on. They’ll request contracts and insurance information well before filing suit. These records help determine whether any party had a duty that they failed to uphold. In many cases, that includes vehicle maintenance, driver supervision, or route planning responsibilities.

When a crash happens, no one points fingers faster than subcontractors. A lawyer will take that into account, knowing that each party will try to shift the blame elsewhere. Gathering solid documentation before litigation begins makes it harder for companies to duck responsibility later.

Government Entities and Road Conditions: Accountability Beyond the Truck

Truck accidents often bring driver error or company negligence to mind, but the road itself can sometimes be the true culprit. A missing guardrail, an unmarked drop-off, or a crumbling shoulder might seem minor until they’re responsible for a devastating crash. If you suffered an injury on a poorly maintained, designed, or marked road, a public agency can be on the hook.

Why Most People Don’t Think to Blame the Government

You’re not alone if you’ve never considered suing a government agency. Most people don’t. But when public roads create danger, someone has to take responsibility. A truck accident lawyer will look at whether the agency in charge had a duty to address the hazard and whether they ignored clear signs of danger. That includes reviewing resident complaints, construction project schedules, and inspection logs – evidence that doesn’t just sit out in the open.

Understanding the Unique Challenges of Government Claims

These cases are different from the standard claims process. Public entities follow strict rules. Deadlines, known as “notice of claim” periods, can be as short as 90 days. Paperwork has to be submitted in a particular format. And government bodies often rely on “sovereign immunity” to dodge lawsuits altogether. A truck accident attorney will know how to navigate those barriers. For example, they’ll work quickly to gather records from agencies like the local Department of Transportation and track which department had control over the dangerous stretch of highway.

Pinpointing Which Government Body Was Responsible

Understanding who’s responsible isn’t just about the nearest town or the name on the exit sign. Roads are often split between state, city, and county control. Maintenance responsibilities can shift without warning. Your attorney will identify the right agency early and hold them accountable before your claim falls outside the allowable timeframe.

When Delivery Vehicles Are Involved

You see them everywhere now – branded delivery vans parked outside homes, zipping down narrow roads, or rushing through intersections. But figuring out who’s behind the wheel is more complicated than it used to be. The driver might be working for a contractor. The truck might be leased. The brand on the side might not match the name on the insurance policy. But even if the relationships are layered and confusing, responsibility still travels upstream.

When Major Retailers Retain Control Behind the Scenes

If a delivery driver working for a major retailer crashed into your vehicle, it’s possible that the company had more control than it wants to admit. A knowledgeable truck accident lawyer will trace those connections by digging through records the average person doesn’t even know exist. Corporate filings, transportation contracts, and internal delivery schedules all help tell the real story.

Dangerous Delivery Timelines Can Lead to Risky Roads

Sometimes, the problem isn’t just the driver but the policies that put them on the road. Companies that rely on tight delivery windows often create unrealistic expectations. Drivers may be pressured to skip required rest periods or ignore traffic laws just to stay on pace. That pressure translates into risk, and if it played a role in your crash, a truck accident attorney will find the paper trail.

Digging into Internal Records to Reveal the Truth

Uncovering that pressure isn’t easy. These companies don’t advertise the fact that they push drivers too hard. But your legal representative knows where to look. They’ll issue discovery requests, review driver logs, and pinpoint how internal demands led to external harm. It’s not just about naming names but about proving the system was flawed.

When Liability Is Shared Between Parties: Untangling a Web of Responsibility

Liability note  text on wood

Truck crashes don’t always have a single cause. Often, they result from a combination of overlooked warnings, bad decisions, and cutting corners. Maybe the truck’s brakes were worn down, and the driver didn’t react in time. Or maybe the company skipped an inspection and kept the vehicle on the road anyway. Add in a faulty road surface, and suddenly, you’re looking at a chain of failures rather than a single mistake.

Mapping Out the Key Players Behind the Crash

This is where pre-litigation work becomes crucial. Before your case goes anywhere near a courtroom, a truck accident lawyer will map out the players involved. They’ll look at who hired the driver, maintained the vehicle, owned the cargo, and managed the route. It’s not just about pointing fingers – it’s about building a cohesive narrative that shows how each party’s actions fit into the bigger picture.

Preserving Evidence Before It’s Gone for Good

That story is built with evidence that disappears fast. Surveillance footage can be erased. Phone records may get overwritten. Trucks are often sent back into service quickly, wiping digital logs clean. Askilled truck accident attorney will act fast to preserve that data. They’ll request black box downloads, grab time-stamped GPS routes, and gather inspection reports while they’re still fresh.

Why Shared Blame Doesn’t Mean Shared Escape

When multiple companies share blame, each one tries to dodge responsibility. But your lawyer won’t let them. Instead of letting them push the blame in circles, your attorney will lock down the facts and keep the focus on how their choices hurt you. It doesn’t matter if the driver made a mistake, the maintenance crew skipped a step, or the trucking company ignored obvious risks – when they each had a role, they each have to answer for it.

A Skilled Truck Accident Attorney Will Put the Puzzle Together

Before you even consider filing a lawsuit, a truck accident lawyer will start untangling those connections. They’ll find out who put the wheels in motion and hold each one accountable. Whether it’s a company that overlooked safety, a subcontractor that cut corners, or a manufacturer that released a dangerous product, your personal injury attorney will build the case from the ground up long before it ever reaches a courtroom. Contact a lawyer for a free case evaluation by calling or contacting them online.

Schedule A Free Consultation Today

Safeguard Your Future with Professional Legal Support

Recent Victories for Clients

$36M

Santa Fe Jury Verdict

$1M

Motorcycle Accident

$900K

Estate of Bennie Hargrove

Gauthier & Maier Law Firm, P.C. Logo
505-226-3205
Los Lunas
3457 Highway 47, Suite B
Los Lunas, NM 87031
505-226-3205
505-560-7226 (fax)
Girard Office
2741 Indian School Road NE, Suite 209
Albuquerque, NM 87106
505-226-3205
505-560-7226 (fax)
  • Home
  • About Our Firm
  • Recommendations
  • Site Map
  • FAQ
  • Practice Areas
  • Blog
Connect With Us

© 2025 Gauthier & Maier Law Firm, P.C. | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | All rights reserved.